Supreme Court sentence father of five to death


The Supreme Court in Abuja yesterday affirmed the death sentence handed out to a farmer and father of five, Mr. James Afolabi.
A five-man panel of the apex court held that there was no basis to disturb the concurrent findings of the lower courts in their previous judgments.

Afolabi, an indigene of Kogi State, was convicted and sentenced to death by the Kogi State High Court, Lokoja in 2012, having been found guilty for the murder of a Fulani man, Abubakar Mohammed.

The court relied on Afolabi’s confessional statement to the police, where he claimed to have shot Mohammed in the chest for straying into his (Afolabi’s) yam and cassava farm on February 27, 2009.

The Court of Appeal, Abuja on March 22, 2012 dismissed his appeal and upheld the decision of the trial court; a decision he appealed to the Supreme Court.

On Friday,  Justice John Inyang Okoro, in the lead judgment, in the appeal marked SC/181/2012, held that although the prosecution could not produce an eyewitness at trial, it provided sufficient evidence, through its witnesses, “which gave vent to the confession of the appellant.”

“And in any case, this court held in Mohammed v State (2007) 11 NWLR (pt 1045) 303 at 230 paragraph F that where an accused person confesses to a , in the absence of an eyewitness of the killing, he can be convicted on his confession alone.

“For all I have said, I hold a strong view that the court below was on a strong wicket when it upheld the conviction and sentencing of the appellant upon reliance on his confessional statements,” he said.


Leave a Reply